Evil and suffering is a problem for religious believers as it challenges the existence of god j l mackie argued that the existence of an all loving and powerful god, and the existence of evil and suffering is incompatible, and this results in the inconsistent one solution to the problem of suffering is the augustian theodicy. Several attempts have been made to solve this problem, some adequate and some not (see j l mackie's evil and omnipotence much of the handout below is a summary of mackie's points in this article) the adequate responses will simply reject either one of (1) through (4) above if one denies that. As i see it there is one significant error in the article on the logical problem of evil on the iep website in section 8 called 'was plantinga's victory too easy' the author claims this quote from mackie is a response to plantinga's free-will defense: “since this defense is formally [that is, logically] possible, and. Mackie, then, explores some common theist responses to these questions and attempts to prove them illogical he states that if one accepts that evil exists, then he or she cannot accept that god is both omnipotent and morally perfect mackie says that a solution to this problem of evil is to either believe that. Evil and omnipotence jl mackie problem of evil 1 problem of evil proves belief in god irrational (not just non-rational) a when problems are found with even if every quality must have a real opposite, this provides no solution to problem of evil, unless one is willing to say, there is just enough evil to serve as a.
The logical problem of evil and suffering • jl mackie and the 'inconsistent triad' (from 'evil and omnipotence', 1955) god's omnipotence evil exists god's omnibenevolence • the combination of any of these two positions leads logically to the third being impossible • however, theists wish to maintain that. On what ground does he refute the christian science solution to the problem of evil how does he refute the personalist mackie—god could create wholly good persons a wholly good person is a logical impossibility, a meaningless conjunction of words evil exists augustine—evil is not created by. This essay examines one form the argument from evil has taken, which is known as the logical problem of evil in the second half of the twentieth century, atheologians (that is, persons who try to prove the non-existence of god) commonly claimed that the problem of evil was a problem of logical inconsistency j l mackie.
Articles god and evil if god is such a nice guy, why is there so much misery and suffering in the world kola abimbola examines an ancient problem one of the principal challenges to the belief in god is the problem of evil jl mackie stated the problem as follows:god is omnipotent: god is wholly good, and yet evil. Read this full essay on solution to mackie's problem of evil the problem of evilif you had only one wish to be granted, it would seem non-evil and purely go. The success of the theodicies as a response to the problem of evil • what poses the greatest challenge to faith in god – natural evil or moral evil • is free will a satisfactory explanation for the existence of evil in a world created by god the philosopher mackie argued that god could have created humans whose nature is.
Mackie notes: if you are prepared to say that god is not wholly good, or not quite omnipotent, or that evil does not exist, or that good is not opposed to the kind of evil that exists, or that there are limits to what an omnipotent thing can do, then the problem of evil will not arise for you but the theist is not. Adequate solutions an 'adequate solution' must remove the inconsistency so, given that there is a real logical incompatibility between three claims, an adequate solution must backtrack, ie it must withdraw (at least) one of the claims generally, the withdrawn claim is replaced by a similar but weaker claim that – satisfies. This answer is insufficient to solve the problem because every manner of defending it has failed over time to explain how a deity that is all perfect and in particular all knowing and all powerful and all good would permit or allow or cause evil to exist how would a deity that knows the future be all good if the deity creates. One of the more striking illustrations of this phenomenon is provided by alvin plantinga's discussions of the problem of evil in god and other minds, in the nature of necessity, and in god, freedom, and evil, for example, plantinga, starting out from an examination of john l mackie's essay “evil and.
1 the theological problem of evil is a problem that many philosophers have tried to solve the problem is stated as, “if one believes that god is omnipotent and wholly good, why does evil still exist” in this writing i will discuss the solutions/ propositions of john l mackie in his work, “evil and omnipotence” i will do. An omnipotent thing can do, then the problem of evil will not arise for you there are, then, quite a number of adequate solutions of the problem of evil, and some of these have been adopted, or almost adopted, by various thinkers for example , a few have been prepared to deny god's omnipotence, and. Free problem of evil papers, essays, and research papers (10) b) outline two solutions to these problems and comment on their success (10) a) the problem of suffering has been around since the dawn of time, or as religious philosophers believe [tags: philosophy philosophical evil mackie essays], 1664 words.